Barely five centimetres high, this densely worked drawing concentrates its effect on the emergence of a face from surrounding darkness. Closely layered pen strokes describe the enveloping headdress and clothing, while passages of exposed paper illuminate the cheek and nose. The tightly enclosed composition gives the small head an unexpectedly forceful presence.
The drawing belongs to Whistler’s early American years and to a group associated with Maria “Kitty” Bailey, daughter of Jacob Whitman Bailey, professor of chemistry at West Point. Nancy Dorfman Pressly recorded it as one of four drawings from her album, alongside two prison scenes and a girl carrying a lamp. Their association places the sheet within the young artist’s interest in dramatic costume and strongly contrasted lighting. Maria’s death in July 1852 provides an upper limit for the recorded gift.
A particularly revealing comparison is furnished by Sketches on the Coast Survey Plate, etched in 1854 during Whistler’s employment in Washington. The Glasgow catalogue specifically relates the hooded head on that plate to the present drawing and to Head of a Man in a Cloak in Pelouze’s album. This recurrence suggests that the shadowed, elaborately wrapped head formed part of a repertoire that Whistler carried from pen drawing into his early printmaking. It does not, however, establish the identity of the figure or a direct preparatory relationship between the works.
Seen in this context, the drawing offers an intimate record of Whistler exploring the expressive possibilities of line. Its drama depends on the varying density and direction of the hatching - contours dissolve into shadow, and the face becomes legible through small reserves of light. The subject remains unidentified, but the sheet’s combination of minute scale and concentrated tonal activity makes it a compelling example of his youthful draughtsmanship.
Provenance
Maria Whitman Bailey (1836–1852), West Point, New York, USA; a gift from the artistProfessor Jacob Whitman Bailey (1811–1857), West Point, New York, USA; by inheritance from his daughter
Dr Loring Woart Bailey, Fredericton, New Brunswick, Canada
Laurenstein M. Bailey, Fredericton, New Brunswick, Canada; by descent from the above
Marshall D’Avray West, Fredericton, New Brunswick, Canada
Lord and Lady Beaverbrook
Canadian Beaverbrook Foundation, Fredericton, New Brunswick; deaccessioned to benefit art purchases at the Beaverbrook Art Gallery, Fredericton, New Brunswick
Literature
Beaverbrook Art Gallery, Beaverbrook Art Gallery: [Paintings], 1st ed., Fredericton, 1959, p. 69.Susan Clayton, ‘Kitty’s Whistlers in the Beaverbrook Collection’, The Atlantic Advocate, vol. 50, no. 1, September 1959, pp. 40–42 and 45, illustrated p. 45
Nancy Dorfman Pressly, ‘Whistler in America: An Album of Early Drawings’, The Metropolitan Museum Journal, 5 (1972), pp. 125–154, specifically p. 153, no. 67, as ‘Head of a Man’
M.F. MacDonald, James McNeill Whistler. Drawings, Pastels and Watercolours. A Catalogue Raisonné, New Haven and London, 1995, 26, no. 87